A Short Defense Of “Leaks”

Several years ago I got an interesting communication, from someone within the Missouri state bureaucracy, telling me to ask for a specifically titled internal  Memo.

I did – and got stonewalled.  I reached out to a couple of friendly legislators.  They heard a lot of excuses but never saw the Memo.  I reached out to a friend in the Department of Social Services who looked into the matter and said “You really don’t want to see that.”

Yeah, they knew that wouldn’t stop me.

It turned out several good people about the state received similar communications referencing this Memo.

Well, due to problems with two antiquated computer systems not talking to each other, Missouri had accidentally charged the federal government for more food stamps for more people than our state actually distributed. 

Fortunately, internal systems caught this error in a bit less than seven years. Our state owed a few hundred million dollars to Washington.  And, several years of routine reports on Missouri food stamp use were very wrong.

I remain convinced that without that ‘leaked’ invitation to track-down that Memo the state might never have admitted its mistake.

As anyone who has talked their ways through the halls of the Capitol in Jefferson City knows, the Missouri legislature survives on caffeine, free food and gossip.  No high school in Missouri can propel gossip faster than our Capitol.  Though much of that noise is unsubstantiated and unflattering, virtually every item in state government speeds up the stairways long before the information becomes public.  (This includes a long list of sexual hijinks by elected folks.)

The state bureaucracy is not much better at keeping secrets.  People talk.  They talk when they’re angry, when they’re happy or when the week has a Tuesday in it.  True, no one is forced to listen but, then again, no one was forced to buy Fifty Shades of Grey (but millions did).

So it is with amusement that I listen to President Donald Trump claim that the ‘real crime’ was the leak about National Security Advisor Michael Flynn’s call to one of his favorite Russians.  No sir, the crime was what General Flynn said and promised.  The leak exposed his crime.  Without the leak the crime might have always remain unpunished.

Without leaks how would we have learned about massive spying campaigns on fellow Americans?  Or President Richard Nixon’s treachery?  Though messy, leaks are a vital safety valve.  Let’s hope they don’t stop.

Oh yes, I was in the Capitol this Tuesday:  interested in some grade B+ gossip?

Submitted by Glenn Koenen, WCD Member