A Holdings Tax?

This month California failed to pass a ballot measure creating a new tax on billionaires.

Not a surprise:  killing the measure saved rich people a lot of money.  Of course they spent real money to kill it.

That tax wasn’t a bad idea.  And, the publicity around the California dream exposed a lot of the tricks the super rich use to avoid taxes.  As the New York Times Magazine [10/21/26] pointed out, the super rich take out a loan using stock or property as collateral.  The money realized isn’t taxed, nor is the money they pay (eventually) to cover the loan.  If you’re worth $10 billion, a loan for a hundred million a year is pretty efficient.

Likewise, trusts and foreign holdings can make a multi-billionaire look like a pauper – and let him pay less in income tax than one of his gardeners.

Missouri holds a number of billionaires (and many closing in on that guidepost) and we already know that they get a Show Me discount on their effective tax rate.  As the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP) points out, the top 1% of Missourians by wealth pay just 5.7% of their income to the state – compared to an effective tax rate of 9.8% for those struggling on $20,000 a year. [ITEP.org]

Remember, the state of Missouri’s Republican “leadership” has spent 20+ years reducing the state’s revenue.  They’ve lowered the top income tax from 6% to 4.7%.  They eliminated the state capital gains tax.  They’ve created generous tax credits for private schools, pregnancy resource centers and other niche causes.

In August they tried to completely eliminate the income tax.  Already several GOP lawmakers threaten further revenue cuts to come in the next legislative session.

Meanwhile, back at reality, the state board of education decided not to even ask for the $300 million in additional, needed school funding promised by past legislation. In addition (as we’ve discussed) the;m One Big Beautiful Bill Act shifts billions of dollars in costs for food stamps, Medicaid, children’s services, child care and assorted other ‘luxuries’ on to Missouri general revenue.

Think $3 billion a year in new costs.

Don’t tax you, don’t tax me, tax the fellow behind the tree.  Sen. Russell Long, 1973

I propose a Missouri Holdings Tax.

The simple definition:  if you have it, the state gets, say, 1%.

Okay, on the base Missouri income tax form we add a new section, a brief Balance Sheet:

          Value of all stocks and investments

          Value of all real estate

          Value of personal property

          Cash in the bank

The data is already available.  Investments yield 1099 forms and Annual Reports.  Every piece of real estate has a tax value, as do cars, boats, planes and such.  And, everyone gets statements on cash accounts.

So, do your regular tax calculations and put down the Adjusted Gross Income subject to tax.  Total the Balance Sheet, calculate 1%.  Pay which ever amount is higher.  I bet for 95% of filers the larger number is that traditional tax.

Now, a lot of investment people show even middle class folks how to minimize tax exposure using trusts and deferred income plans… Not anymore.  If it’s yours you add it in.

Own a billion dollars worth of stuff but your typical Missouri income is just $60,000?  Your tax bill just jumped to $10 million.

Yes, this would have to go to voters.  They’ll have a choice.  Let rich people help keep schools open, or, let the rich shirk their responsibility to their neighbors?

Remember, Missouri state government is rooted in classic socialism.  Take money from urban, more prosperous areas to pay for schools, roads, and (after last week) rural sheriff’s pensions in less wealthy places.

Governor Mike Kehoe has repeatedly stated that we are a Christian state: ‘from each according to his ability, to each according to their need’  was in The Acts of The Apostles long before Karl Marx stole the phrase. Strong moral people who believe in Jesus want to help their neighbors, right?

Glenn Koenen

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.